The current trade tensions between the United States and Canada have created significant challenges for businesses on both sides of the border. With the implementation of 25% tariffs on Canadian imports to the US and Canada’s retaliatory measures, e-commerce businesses are facing a new economic reality that demands strategic adaptation. As a fractional CFO working with numerous e-commerce companies, I’ve observed firsthand how businesses are pivoting to not only survive but thrive in this changing landscape.

The Current Tariff Situation

The United States imposed a 25% tariff on most Canadian goods beginning February 1, 2025, citing national security concerns and border issues. In response, Canada implemented countermeasures in multiple phases:

• March 4, 2025: 25% tariffs on $30 billion worth of US goods
• March 13, 2025: Additional 25% tariffs on US steel, aluminum, and other products
• April 9, 2025: 25% tariffs on non-USMCA compliant vehicles and components

These measures have disrupted established supply chains and forced businesses to reconsider their operational strategies. The tariffs affect approximately 16% of Canada’s total exports to the United States, creating significant economic pressure on Canadian businesses.

Strategic Adaptations by Canadian E-commerce Businesses

Domestic Market Refocus

One of the most notable shifts has been the pivot toward domestic alternatives. Four in five Canadian businesses report being impacted by the US-Canada trade war, leading many to reduce US investments while strengthening their presence in the Canadian market.

The “Buy Canadian” movement has gained significant momentum, with consumers increasingly choosing domestic products over American alternatives. This shift in consumer behavior has created new opportunities for e-commerce businesses that can effectively position themselves as Canadian alternatives to US products.

Supply Chain Restructuring

Direct Sourcing Benefits

Some manufacturers have discovered unexpected advantages from the tariffs. For example, companies like IdealCan Inc. now secure better pricing by dealing directly with overseas steel mills instead of routing through American distributors. This direct sourcing approach not only reduces costs but also builds more resilient supply chains.

Canadian manufacturers are also finding new opportunities to engage with domestic suppliers that were previously difficult to access when competing against larger US buyers. This restructuring of supply relationships is creating a more integrated Canadian manufacturing ecosystem.

Financial Strategy Adjustments

As a fractional CFO for e-commerce businesses, I’ve helped clients implement several financial strategies to navigate the tariff situation:

1. Comprehensive Tariff Impact Assessment: Using tools like PwC’s Tariff Impact Assessment to visualize supply chain vulnerabilities and identify areas of exposure to US tariffs or Canadian surtaxes.
2. Strategic Pricing Adjustments: Businesses are carefully recalibrating their pricing strategies to accommodate increased costs while remaining competitive.
3. Cash Flow Forecasting: Enhanced cash flow monitoring and forecasting has become essential for maintaining financial stability during this period of uncertainty.
4. Working Capital Optimization: Strategies to maximize available working capital help businesses maintain operations despite potential disruptions.

Market Diversification Strategies

The tariff situation has accelerated the push for market diversification beyond the US. This strategy involves:

• Exploring international alternatives in Europe, Asia, and other regions
• Establishing new trade relationships and distribution networks
• Navigating different regulatory environments and compliance requirements
• Developing marketing strategies tailored to new target markets

While diversification requires significant investment in time and resources, it creates long-term resilience by reducing dependency on a single market.

Leveraging Government Support Programs

The Canadian government has implemented several support measures to help businesses navigate the tariff situation:

• Financial Aid and Tax Relief: Including corporate income tax payment and GST/HST remittance deferrals from April 2 to June 30, 2025, providing up to $40 billion in liquidity.
• Tariff Relief Programs: The Canada Border Services Agency’s Duties Relief Program and Duty Drawback Program allow businesses to import commercial goods without paying tariffs or receive refunds for tariffs paid on goods eventually exported.
• Workforce Management Support: Programs like the Employment Insurance Work-Sharing Program and Supplemental Unemployment Benefit Plans help manage temporary workforce disruptions.
• United States Surtax Remission Order (2025): Provides time-limited relief for imports from March 4 to October 15, 2025, supporting Canadian businesses that rely on US inputs.

Industry-Specific Opportunities

Manufacturing Revival

The current situation presents opportunities to strengthen domestic manufacturing, particularly for construction materials and other essential goods. Small to medium-sized Canadian businesses are exploring production of items like nails, screws, insulation, and other structural elements required for construction.

As one Reddit user noted: “I believe we should begin with manageable steps by focusing on the pressing manufacturing needs of our society. One critical issue that stands out to me is the housing crisis. Picture small to medium-sized Canadian businesses producing essential materials such as nails, screws, insulation, and other structural elements required for constructing homes.”

E-commerce Fulfillment Strategies

E-commerce businesses are revising their warehousing and fulfillment strategies to adapt to the new tariff environment. Some are exploring:

• Establishing US-based fulfillment centers to avoid cross-border tariffs
• Negotiating better bulk shipping rates to offset increased costs
• Implementing more efficient inventory management systems to reduce carrying costs

Consumer Behavior Shifts

American CPG CEOs have issued warnings that the Canadian market is shifting dramatically. According to reports from Telesto Strategy, “U.S. executives are reporting that their Canadian retail partners are either halting or reducing their orders. This shift appears to be a response to changing consumer preferences in Canada, where shoppers are increasingly opting for domestically produced items or goods from the EU and other international markets instead of American products.”

This consumer-driven change creates both challenges and opportunities for e-commerce businesses. Those that can effectively position themselves as Canadian alternatives to US products may find new growth opportunities in this environment.

Financial Planning Considerations for E-commerce Businesses

As a fractional CFO specializing in e-commerce and CPG brands, I recommend several financial planning considerations for businesses navigating the current tariff situation:

1. Scenario Planning: Develop multiple financial scenarios based on different tariff outcomes and market responses.
2. Cost Structure Analysis: Identify areas where costs can be reduced to offset tariff-related increases.
3. Investment Prioritization: Focus investments on areas that strengthen domestic market position and reduce dependency on US trade.
4. Performance Metrics Adjustment: Revise KPIs and performance metrics to reflect the new operating environment.
5. Cash Reserve Strategy: Build stronger cash reserves to weather potential disruptions and capitalize on emerging opportunities.

The De Minimis Challenge for Cross-Border E-commerce

A significant change affecting e-commerce businesses is the elimination of the De Minimis exemption for shipments under $800 USD from certain countries. This change, effective May 2, 2025, means that even small parcels now face import fees, creating new challenges for cross-border e-commerce.

Canadian e-commerce businesses selling to US customers need to consider:

• Transparent communication with customers about potential duties and taxes
• Adjusting pricing strategies to account for the additional costs
• Exploring fulfillment options within the US to avoid cross-border shipping issues

According to Shippo’s analysis, e-commerce merchants are “grappling with tighter margins; inventory and cash flow challenges; increased friction in global sales; new compliance burdens like updated HS codes and origin labels; and customer churn when unexpected duties show up at delivery.”

The Reality of Supply Chain Adaptation

While diversification is a key strategy, it’s important to recognize the challenges involved. As CTV News reports, “The notion that Canadian companies can simply switch supply chains in response to American tariffs is a fantasy.”

Businesses caught in tightly integrated supply chains after decades of trade agreements face significant barriers to rapid adaptation, including:

• Transport and labor costs
• Resource availability
• Manufacturing capacity
• Market saturation

As Ulrich Paschen from Kwantlen Polytechnic University’s Melville School of Business notes, “There are many, many industries that can’t just flip a switch.”

Economic Impact of the “Buy Canadian” Movement

Despite these challenges, there’s a silver lining. According to BMO’s analysis, the “Buy Canadian” movement could add approximately $10 billion annually to the Canadian economy, potentially boosting economic growth by 0.3 percentage points within a year.

BMO senior economist Robert Kavcic describes this as “behavioral economics at work” and suggests that “the effects should be noticeable.” This growth would be driven by changes in consumer habits, government purchases, and increased domestic travel.

The Role of Fractional CFOs in Navigating Tariff Challenges

For e-commerce and CPG businesses facing these complex challenges, fractional CFO services have become increasingly valuable. These professionals bring specialized expertise in:

• Cash Flow Management: Optimizing cash flow to ensure operational stability during periods of trade uncertainty
• Financial Analysis: Providing detailed analysis of how tariffs impact different aspects of the business
• Strategic Planning: Developing financial roadmaps that account for changing tariff scenarios
• Inventory Optimization: Managing inventory levels to minimize tariff exposure while maintaining adequate stock
• Fundraising Readiness: Preparing businesses for potential capital needs during market disruptions

As Clearco notes, fractional CFOs specializing in e-commerce and CPG brands bring “a wealth of knowledge and applicable skills across a hyper-targeted area of focus,” making them ideal partners for navigating the specific challenges of the current tariff situation.

Key Metrics Fractional CFOs Monitor During Tariff Disruptions

When helping e-commerce businesses adapt to tariffs, fractional CFOs focus on optimizing several critical metrics:

• Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC): Analyzing which marketing channels deliver the best results and developing strategies to reduce acquisition costs in a challenging market
• Customer Lifetime Value (CLV): Identifying the most valuable customer segments and implementing strategies to increase CLV through loyalty programs, subscription models, and targeted upsell campaigns
• Gross Margin: Closely monitoring how tariffs impact product margins and implementing pricing or sourcing strategies to maintain profitability
• Inventory Turnover: Optimizing inventory levels to reduce exposure to tariff changes while ensuring product availability

Conclusion: Turning Challenge into Opportunity

While the current tariff situation presents significant challenges for Canadian e-commerce businesses, it also creates opportunities for those that can adapt strategically. By refocusing on the domestic market, restructuring supply chains, diversifying internationally, and leveraging government support programs, businesses can not only survive but potentially emerge stronger.

The tariff situation has accelerated trends that were already underway, including the push for greater supply chain resilience, market diversification, and domestic manufacturing capacity. E-commerce businesses that can successfully navigate these changes will be well-positioned for long-term success in the evolving North American trade landscape.

For businesses seeking to optimize their financial strategies during this period, working with a fractional CFO specialized in e-commerce and CPG can provide the expertise needed to turn these challenges into opportunities for growth and innovation.

As a fractional CFO working with e-commerce and CPG businesses, I help companies navigate complex financial challenges like the current tariff situation. Contact us to discuss how strategic financial leadership can help your business adapt and thrive in changing market conditions.

Dive Deeper: More Tariff Insights for E-commerce & CPG Brands

Looking to better understand how tariffs impact your e-commerce or CPG business? Explore these related resources:

Learn how fractional CFOs help e-commerce brands leverage funding – Explore how specialized financial leadership can help secure and optimize funding during market disruptions.

Navigate the financial complexities of Trump’s tariff policies – Learn strategic shifts for growth including supply chain restructuring, market diversification, and financial planning considerations.

Discover how Canadian businesses are adapting to US tariffs – Get a data-driven CFO perspective on managing cash flow, inventory, and pricing strategies during trade uncertainty.